Major League Soccer
New York City FC
-
-
DC United
Major League Soccer
New York City FC
-
-
New England Revolution
Major League Soccer
New York City FC
-
-
Montreal Impact
Major League Soccer
New York City FC
-
-
New York Red Bulls
Major League Soccer
New York City FC
-
-
Philadelphia Union
Major League Soccer
New York City FC
-
-
Inter Miami
Major League Soccer
New York City FC
4
2
Orlando City SC
Major League Soccer
New York City FC
2
3
Columbus Crew
Major League Soccer
New York City FC
5
1
San Jose Earthquakes